Rate Thread
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Can't let it go
#11
Maybe no one brought it up to you because no one believed it?
Reply

#12
It is hard from the distance to know that your mother-in-law was branding you a child-abuser.

I think it is possible that she thought she saw what she claimed. A mistaken eyewitness is often convinced of what she "saw."

And child abuse is a pattern, not an outlier. A parent might slap a child in a loss of control, but if it doesn't recur or follow a pattern, I'd never label a parent as a child abuser. Losing a temper once doesn't make the parent an abuser. Getting drunk once doesn't make a person an alcoholic.

The term is too often misused. Not saying that it was in your mother-in-law's case, but it is very difficult to assess the validity of this in such a limited reveal.
Reply

#13
Hardheaded1 Wrote:It is hard from the distance to know that your mother-in-law was branding you a child-abuser.

I think it is possible that she thought she saw what she claimed. A mistaken eyewitness is often convinced of what she "saw."

And child abuse is a pattern, not an outlier. A parent might slap a child in a loss of control, but if it doesn't recur or follow a pattern, I'd never label a parent as a child abuser. Losing a temper once doesn't make the parent an abuser. Getting drunk once doesn't make a person an alcoholic.

The term is too often misused. Not saying that it was in your mother-in-law's case, but it is very difficult to assess the validity of this in such a limited reveal.

She said I hit him with my fist in the stomach, in my book that's child abuse.
As to her thinking she saw it happened, I am sure that in her twisted mind that is what she thought that she saw, often times people see what they are watching for, it's a bit like profiling.
Her attitude was "I know that you must be evil, I will watch for it".
I seldom ever spanked my son, if he got a swat on the butt it was never in anger, mostly to get his attention
I always had a hunch that she was watching for something, I took great care when she was around so that she could make no accusations. Again, people at times see what they believe..
Reply

#14
I'm not dismissing your feelings in any way, but she had antipathy for you. Not sure why the particulars are so rankling.

An enemy can do no good. A friend can do no wrong.

You know you aren't an abuser. Your kid and wife know. Their words should be the standard for your wife's family. Maybe you're concerned that your gay side is going to give them reason to inflate anything else?

Speaking of profiling, do you think any of this is culturally based (i.e. are you "guilty" to them in part because you are a black man who has come out)?

As for abuse, you could have knocked someone backward out of a chair and not been an abuser, only someone who had a violent outburst. Abusers are habitual, just like addicts.
Reply

#15
i wouldn't have seen abuse in this scenario either. i agree with Hardheaded, abuse is a pattern, not a once- or twice-occurring incident.
Reply

#16
I see what all of you are saying about abuse, in my mind if a man hits a woman or a child in a fighting fashion,
I ask "if he does that in front of others, what goes on behind closed doors?".
I have in times past confronted people and intervened by both warning and letting them know that I would be watching.
If I saw a relative hit his son in the gut , we would have a talk, if he blew me off the police would hear from me.
I have zero tolerance for the "one time thing" aspect, if I saw it, I feel a responsibility to stop it.
Reply

#17
The most important is what your son think about this and if this is affecting your relationship with him, at the end your wife's family can think whatever they want but it is your son and you what it counts.
Reply

#18
I can't believe this is going on to a third page of comments without anyone having the nerve to put their finger on the real problem with the OP.... Hell. I'm not afraid to do it.

Here it is.
A 64 year old man said these words...


Quote:........."She past away [SIZE="7"]several years ago[/SIZE]..........
A few years prior to her death she revealed"..........

Here's what I'm seeing.
Son 8 yrs old when father was +/= 40 = 24 years of rumors of child abuse BUT also...
"several years" [SIZE="7"]+ "a few years"
of carrying this drama around.
[/SIZE]

Have you never heard of letting go of things you can do nothing to change?
You know it's not true.
Your son knows it's not true.
Your wife knows it's not true.


[COLOR="Red"][SIZE="7"]Get over and a move on!
All you are doing is letting some dead bitch
have more control over your life
than you're trying to exercise.[/SIZE][/COLOR]
Reply

#19
Virge Wrote:I can't believe this is going on to a third page of comments without anyone having the nerve to put their finger on the real problem with the OP.... Hell. I'm not afraid to do it.

Here it is.
A 64 year old man said these words...




Here's what I'm seeing.
Son 8 yrs old when father was +/= 40 = 24 years of rumors of child abuse BUT also...
"several years" [SIZE="7"]+ "a few years"
of carrying this drama around.
[/SIZE]

Have you never heard of letting go of things you can do nothing to change?
You know it's not true.
Your son knows it's not true.
Your wife knows it's not true.


[COLOR="Red"][SIZE="7"]Get over and a move on!
All you are doing is letting some dead bitch
have more control over your life
than you're trying to exercise.[/SIZE][/COLOR]

What are you trying to say? I know that you are right, no doubt.
Reply

#20
You should have left all this in the past...

There's nothing you can do about it but let it eat at you from the inside which if it's bothering after "several years" + a "few years".... you're hurting yourself by letting it still bother you.

It's not healthy and if you can't get over it, seek help.
Reply



Forum Jump:


Recently Browsing
1 Guest(s)

© 2002-2024 GaySpeak.com