BYoNexus Wrote:I see no logical reason to condemn people who may choose an incest relationship, as long as they dont bear children. That tends to lead to problems for the child and would be unfair to them.
If they are both consenting adults, then it should be fine.
A lot of ppl seem to think there's something inherently wrong with incest here, but the exact same arguments I've seen are exactly the same as arguments against the LGBT community. Switch the word incest with gay.
I haven't read any logical argument as to why its wrong;
"I wouldn't do it, therefore it is wrong"
"I find it weird, therefore it is wrong"
"I find the idea revolting, therefore it is wrong"
Notice how all the arguments hinge on personal feeling on the subject... And completely ignore the people who would actually engage in the incest. You can't say this isn't exactly the same as every argument against gay/lesbian people getting married, Trans being allowed to undergo a sex change, etc.
If they are two consenting adults, who by some happenstance fall in love, there really is no reason anyone can make to say that they should be forced to be apart. It doesn't matter if they're family, its just not something that happens alot.
I too find it weird, and not something I would ever consider, but denying others simply because of that is no better then homophobes who are doing it to people like us
This is pretty much how I feel on the subject.
![[-]](https://gayspeak.com/images/duende_v3_local/collapse.png)
•
BYoNexus Wrote:I see no logical reason to condemn people who may choose an incest relationship, as long as they dont bear children. That tends to lead to problems for the child and would be unfair to them.
If they are both consenting adults, then it should be fine.
A lot of ppl seem to think there's something inherently wrong with incest here, but the exact same arguments I've seen are exactly the same as arguments against the LGBT community. Switch the word incest with gay.
I haven't read any logical argument as to why its wrong;
"I wouldn't do it, therefore it is wrong"
"I find it weird, therefore it is wrong"
"I find the idea revolting, therefore it is wrong"
Notice how all the arguments hinge on personal feeling on the subject... And completely ignore the people who would actually engage in the incest. You can't say this isn't exactly the same as every argument against gay/lesbian people getting married, Trans being allowed to undergo a sex change, etc.
If they are two consenting adults, who by some happenstance fall in love, there really is no reason anyone can make to say that they should be forced to be apart. It doesn't matter if they're family, its just not something that happens alot.
I too find it weird, and not something I would ever consider, but denying others simply because of that is no better then homophobes who are doing it to people like us
I would agree, though by me stating that I don't personally find it something that'd approve of, I'm not denying anyone. Just stating my opinion.
Generally speaking, two consenting adults can do what they want for all I care.
•
Posts: 22,369
Threads: 166
Joined: Aug 2011
Reputation:
0
I'm a : Single Gay Man
Starsign:  Capricorn
Mood:
I'm suddenly remembering "Flowers In The Attic".
![[Image: 51806835273_f5b3daba19_t.jpg]](https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51806835273_f5b3daba19_t.jpg) <<< It's mine!
•
Just to add a bit of truth here… incest is wrong. Just because it doesnt directly effect you or people dont get hurt, doesnt make anything ok about it.
•
Joshular Wrote:>.o I know right. I just love grave digging on a Monday night!
Gives new meaning to the term "diggin up an old boyfriend"!!!!!
•
If you want to get "biblical", then incest is best, by religious standards.
Adam and Eve had two boys, Cane and Abel.
WHO do you think Cane and Abel had to fuck in order to get more people????
Or even if Adam and Eve had more kids until they got a girl out of it.....daddy had to fuck HER or her brothers did!!!!
They had to keep fucking each other..................according to current religious teachings....
Even in some religious sects, it is said that Adam, Eve, and the boys went in search of others and found them.
This is what I consider the FIRST BLATANT BOLDFACED LIE in religious "history"......if Adam and Eve were supposed to be the FIRST people created, and we were supposed to come from their lineage, then HOW THE FUCK did they find OTHER people?????
Lies and deceit. Nothing but lies and deceit.
•
I don't really blame people for opposing incest but there are pretty much no valid, rational arguments to do so. The only decent argument against incest I've heard is the whole family-hierarchy thing, but if we start banning relationships because of an assumed power unbalance then we have plenty of other areas to cover.
•
MisterTinkles Wrote:If you want to get "biblical", then incest is best, by religious standards.
Adam and Eve had two boys, Cane and Abel.
WHO do you think Cane and Abel had to fuck in order to get more people????
Or even if Adam and Eve had more kids until they got a girl out of it.....daddy had to fuck HER or her brothers did!!!!
They had to keep fucking each other..................according to current religious teachings....
Even in some religious sects, it is said that Adam, Eve, and the boys went in search of others and found them.
This is what I consider the FIRST BLATANT BOLDFACED LIE in religious "history"......if Adam and Eve were supposed to be the FIRST people created, and we were supposed to come from their lineage, then HOW THE FUCK did they find OTHER people?????
Lies and deceit. Nothing but lies and deceit.
You forgot to mention Steve, he was there too...lol
•
Good thread, interesting topic.
Personally, I hold to this: -
When a relationship is consentual, and mutually benifical it's not for me to sit in judgment.
I would however caution hetrosexuals who practice incest to ensure that there are no off-spring.
•
MisterTinkles Wrote:If you want to get "biblical", then incest is best, by religious standards.
Adam and Eve had two boys, Cane and Abel.
WHO do you think Cane and Abel had to fuck in order to get more people????
Or even if Adam and Eve had more kids until they got a girl out of it.....daddy had to fuck HER or her brothers did!!!!
They had to keep fucking each other..................according to current religious teachings....
Even in some religious sects, it is said that Adam, Eve, and the boys went in search of others and found them.
This is what I consider the FIRST BLATANT BOLDFACED LIE in religious "history"......if Adam and Eve were supposed to be the FIRST people created, and we were supposed to come from their lineage, then HOW THE FUCK did they find OTHER people?????
Lies and deceit. Nothing but lies and deceit.
To be honest if you study the bible. Like I do. It says Adam and Eve were the first people god created. It doesn't say they were the only. And Adam and Eve had more than 2 kids. It just tells about the 2.
I'm not against insect I'm jus saying what I know from the bible.
It is not for me to judge if two people love each other.
•
|
