Posts: 2,797
Threads: 40
Joined: May 2009
Reputation:
0
I'm a : Gay Man in an Open Gay Relationship
Starsign: Virgo
Mood:
princealbertofb Wrote:At least the churches won't be given the right to oppose secular / civil marriages.
They
do have that right.
And they can oppose it much as they like.(and they are)
Unfortunately for them, they don't have any secular reasons to keep same-sex civil marriage illegal, so they can't get their way, no matter how much they cry "undemocratic"; at least until they find a compelling secular reason.
As the UK government and laws functions on a secular basis now-a-days, something churches and religious groups still need to get to grips with apparently.
Silly Sarcastic So-and-so
•
Let me rephrase that.... They might have the right to oppose them but they wouldn't be able to undo them, if civil / secular same sex marriage were lawful. Their only right would be to refuse to perform them in their churches, which is what I meant by that.
•
Maybe there is a difference in France and the UK that you don't know about. In France all marriages have to be secular and civil at least. The church has no power to make a civil / secular marriage exist, so all marriages have to be recorded at the town hall.
The church wedding is a ceremony which aims to enshrine the wedding in a faith system. It cannot be substituted for the civil wedding. Sometimes, couples will go for their civil wedding on a week day and then have the religious ceremony some time later, generally a Saturday, so that the wedding party can follow with all their guests. People who do not wish for a religious ceremony of any kind can opt for the civil ceremony alone.
In the UK, weddings performed by churches have the same validity as the secular / civil weddings, which is where our two countries differ, because it means that churches have the power to deliver valid wedding certificates, which certificates attest that the couple has all the rights that civil marriages afford (no more, no less). In France, such a religious certificate would have no other validity than to say that a religious ceremony had been performed (no rights attached).
•