*Shrug* - I have no idea what you should do.
I know for myself I came up with a few simple 'rules' to guide me through life and when it comes to relationships I have a few make and break rules - such as no hitting - hit me once I'm out the door and you never see me again.
What are your deal breakers? Figure them out and use them as a guide.
Quote:and me breaking up with him. (We're still live together, share same bed, etc, til this day).
How exactly is this different than being together?
I just went through a break up, or perhaps we are in the process of breaking up. We now sleep in different beds and we are slowly on raveling our lives from each other, legal stuff, business stuff. We are clear that we are not in a relationship, no sleeping int he same bed, no sex, and he doesn't get the right to call me sweetie anymore.
Seems to me you do not have a defined set of goals between being in a relationship and being out of a relationship.
If you are broke up, then he is dating other fellows. That is to be expected, he is single. But if you two are in a relationship, you might want to let him know that.
So I think your underlying issue is you have poorly defined boundaries. No one can be certain what a relationship is with you, you have no clear 'this will not fly' rules when in a relationship, and you clearly have no idea what your personal needs are and what your personal limits are with pain.
A form of verbal abuse. Verbal abuse causes emotional pain and anguish. That just doesn't go away after time, it sits there and eats away at a person like and acid.
Looking at your list with 'cheats' involved and you seem to think that that is acceptable for a relationship... I have to wonder how much abuse is really being perpetrated by both of you on each other.
If you and he want to stay together, I strongly urge you to seek couples counseling.
In fact this may be a good way to decide right now if its worth carrying on. Are you willing/able to attend years of couples therapy and expose your dark inner core to this man? Are you able/willing to sit there and listen to him gut you like a fresh killed deer as he explored all of the emotional 'damage' he feels he has suffered being with you?
This and much more is included with Couple's Therapy... Is it worth all of that time and effort to remain with him?
Since relationships are two way streets, what does he feel?