Hank you sound a lot like me. I started off my adult life as a Christian conservative (mainly because that's how my parents were), but the whole time I was dealing with my sexuality (or rather trying hard to suppress it) and thinking to myself, "You can't be gay! Look at all the things you stand for!"
I too was doing church work (Youth and Music Ministry, licensed Southern Baptist minister) thinking if I just do "God's work, then these other thoughts and feelings towards other guys will go away. But they didn't go away. In fact they got stronger. And that scared the crap out of me!
So then I met the woman who is now my wife and she kept talking about how she loved me and wanted to spend the rest of her life with me. She had a child from her first marriage, who I eventually adopted after we got married and a few years later we had a son of our own. And for all intents and purposes we were a happy family!
But all this time, I am still dealing with the fact that I am now a married man who finds himself attracted to (both physically and emotionally) to other men! And trust me, I did everything to convince myself that I was not gay, it was just a phase I was going through, and that it would pass.
Flash forward to today and through several years of unhappiness both in my marriage and in my life to where I finally came to grips with my sexuality. I am now a lot happier, even if I'm surrounded by friends and family who at best think I'm just making this up and at worst think they can " cure" me. I am free of trying to change who and what I am. Free from self inflicted guilt for feeling and thinking things I have no control over. Free to be me.
I say all that to tell you this. It get's better! Sure there a good days and bad days, but that's life. Stay true. To yourself and enjoy life. You only get one chance to be who you are!